We Design Your Financial Destiny


(Precious) Words of Wisdom : "Who is the ideal adviser? A person who likes you but doesn't care about your feelings." ~ Daniel Kahneman

Why even the best mutual funds failed to make money for Jiten Singh?

Despite buying "good" mutual funds, Jiten Singh is not making "good" money.  

Every time the NAV appreciates by 10-15%, Jiten sells it and invests in another Mutual Fund Scheme with a lower NAV. 

Here, Jiten makes a very fundamental mistake, in fact, two fundamental mistakes.

The profit-booking strategy that applies to stocks does not hold true for MFs. When you sell a particular stock, you do so because its ‘price’ has overshot its ‘value’. In short, it has become overvalued. 

In a mutual fund, the fund manager is also precisely doing the same. He is regularly booking profits by selling overvalued stocks and buying the under-valued ones. Therefore, despite the fact that its NAV may have gone up, the particular MF may still be a good buy as its ‘new’ portfolio is under-valued.

By selling his MF — purely from a profit booking perspective, Jiten actually ends-up selling a good investment. Hence, he did not make "good" money. Never sell your MF solely based on the appreciation in its NAV.

Since this is important, I repeat, buying mutual funds is different from buying shares directly. So, please do not apply the same logic to both of them.

Second fundamental mistake — NAV of a fund is a ‘useless’ number. Low NAV ‘does not’ imply that it is cheap. Let me try to put it in a different way. If you invest in two funds with the same portfolio (for example an index fund), you will make ‘exactly’ the same returns in both the funds even if one has NAV of Rs 10 and the other Rs 500. [See 'Did you know that NAV of a mutual fund has 'zero' impact on your returns?']

That apart, Jiten is ‘unnecessarily’ piling up transaction costs and taxes that eat into his returns.

Both a Mercedes car and a Tractor are 4-wheelers. Yet, you cannot cultivate your land with a Mercedes car. And it would look pretty stupid to use a tractor to move around in a city. I am sure you get the point.


[An excerpt from 'Your Guide to Finance and Investments']

An Investment In Knowledge Pays The Best Interest ~ Benjamin Franklin

You Learn A Lot By READING... And Even More By SHARING.

Share Button

Ignorance is like a SIGNED BLANK CHEQUE... anyone can MISUSE it.

Subscribe via Email
Powered by Blogger.

... Three VALUABLE Tips ...

1. How Rs.1 Lakh Became Rs.1 Crore In Mutual Fund Scheme
Reliance Growth Fund
Stay invested through all the rough and tough times.

 


2. Guaranteed Income Insurance Plans Misinform Misguide Mislead
Guaranteed Income Insurance Plan
I sincerely hope you spill coffee over guaranteed income insurance form.

 


3. Should You Opt For Home Loan With An Overdraft Facility?
Home Loan With Overdraft Facility
Wondering whether an Overdraft Account linked to Home Loan is Ok or not?