We Design Your Financial Destiny


(Precious) Words of Wisdom : "We don’t have to be smarter than the rest, we have to be more disciplined than the rest." ~ Warren Buffett

IINSS-C : To invest or not to invest

In yesterday's post 'Inflation Indexed National Saving Securities announced', I had listed down the features of the inflation-indexed securities as announced by RBI last week.

Let us now evaluate IINSS-C on the basis of the FIVE parameters on which any investment must be evaluated (as I have done for the 51 most common Investment Products in my latest publication 'Your Guide to Finance and Investments'). 

1. Returns: At 1.5% over and above the inflation, the returns (with around 10% inflation) are 'presently' quite attractive when compared to similar products like Bank FDs, PPF, Tax-free bonds, PO deposits. 

2. Risk: Being issued by Govt. of India, they are 100% safe. However, what if the inflation falls sharply in the future. Then, your returns will too will fall. A 5% inflation would mean return of only 6.5%. After all, we are looking at a 10-year scenario and it is impossible to predict the inflation over such a long term. Whereas in tax-free bonds, PO deposits or bank FDs the returns don't change during the tenure of the investment. (In PPF the rates vary every year). 

3. Time-frame: At 10 years, it is in line with similar investments.

4. Liquidity: Both loan facility and premature withdrawal provide decent liquidity.

5. Taxation: Interest income from IINSS-C is taxable. Therefore, at the present inflation rates (and hence the interest rates), even a person in the highest tax bracket may earn higher returns in IINSS-C vis-a-vis tax-free bonds / PPF. But if the inflation and rates fall, the post-tax returns from IINSS-C would be lower than tax-free bonds/PPF. 

Observation
Hence, while IINSS-C compares quite favourably with other similar investments on Returns, Time-frame and Liquidity, the Risk of falling inflation with consequent drop in interest rate and No Tax breaks are a big negative. So after all the drama, IINSS-Cs are somewhat a disappointment. 

If the product structure had been maintained similar to the inflation indexed bonds issued to the institutional investors a few months earlier, things would have been somewhat better. They are comparatively more tax efficient than IINSS-Cs. So, tax-wise, IINSS-Cs work well for nil/low income tax bracket investors but not for those in higher tax brackets. Conversely, nil/low tax bracket investors may not have the risk appetite for fluctuating interest rates, especially downwards.

Nevertheless, it may not always be an 'either / or' scenario. So you could possibly add IINSS-C to your portfolio for a suitable amount, along with other products; provided, of course, you have the financial and mental capacity to withstand the volatility and fall in the interest rates.

An Investment In Knowledge Pays The Best Interest ~ Benjamin Franklin

101 Classic Tips Money Gyaan

You Learn A Lot By READING... And Even More By SHARING.

Share Button

Ignorance is like a SIGNED BLANK CHEQUE... anyone can MISUSE it.

Subscribe via Email
Powered by Blogger.

... Three VALUABLE Tips ...

1. Stop! Don't Invest In The Stocks Markets (Directly)
Direct Equity or Mutual Funds
Listen to the wise owl. Don't go buying stocks on your own.

 


2. Fake News On Investment (Again): Misleading Annuity Returns
Returns from Annuity Plan
You are far better off skipping the Annuity Schemes.

 


3. Damaged Notes: RBI Rules To Exchange And Claim Refund
RBI Note Refund Rules
Salient aspects of the rules for exchanging damaged currency.